Hydrometer vs Refractometer: Which is better for Home Brewers?

Hydrometers and refractometers, they sound like tools out of a science fiction movie or chemistry classroom. But when it comes to brewing beer, they’re essential tools for measuring the fermentation activity and the final alcohol percentage of your brew.

Today, I’m going to break down these two tools and show you how and why we use them to make the beer of your dreams. I’m Trent Musho, and this is the brew show. It’s brewing tool time.

Hydrometers and refractometers are key tools to have for home brewers and pro brewers. And they’re especially helpful for new brewers to get a good sense of how fermentation works.

Both tools are used to take readings before fermentation and after fermentation to determine the final alcohol percentage, as well as track fermentation progress. Those readings are called your original gravity and final gravity.

That gravity is the total amount of fermentable sugars that are in your wort or beer. And as fermentation is underway, the sugars are eaten by the yeast. And the reading will drop to reflect that.

Without one of these tools, you’re kind of guessing at how strong your beer will be. And you’re also guessing on whether or not your beers done.

There are a few units of measurement for gravity. Specific gravity is written as a one or a zero with three decimal places.

For example, 1.056 or 0.998. The higher the number above one, the more dense with sugars the liquid is. This number is most commonly used with home brewers. And it’s what I use in my beer recipes.

Brix and Plato are another popular option that are most often used by pro brewers. Brix is represented in degrees, Brix and Plato is expressed in degrees Plato. No matter what you choose, they all do the same thing. Tell you how much fermentable sugars are available in your wort or beer.

By using a calculator, you can determine the final alcohol by volume of your beer. Most brewing software has a calculator and there’s some free ones online, but an easy equation is original gravity minus final gravity times 131.25 equals your alcohol by volume.

Let’s take a moment to talk about the differences between hydrometers and refractometers.

Differences between hydrometers & refractometers

Hydrometers use the density of the liquid or how sugary the sample is and floats up or down based on that.

There are small weighted balls inside the hydrometer that when it’s placed in water, the hydrometer floats at a specific gravity of 1.000 or zero Bx. And if there’s sugars in the liquid, it’ll float up.

Hydrometers can have various scales on them, but one of the most popular ones out there show specific gravity brix and even potential alcohol percentage. This is probably the more common tool over refractometers. Since it often comes in starter home brewing kits.

This is one of hydrometers positives, they’re inexpensive and readily available. But on the flip side of that, they’re also very easy to break. Especially if you have one made of glass. I know many brewers who have placed one on a table just to have it roll off and break releasing those tiny beads all over the floor.

Thankfully, they’re now non glass versions of hydrometers that are much more durable.

Low-Tech Pick
Brewer's Elite Hydrometer & Test Jar Combo

This specific gravity hydrometer allows you to easily calculate Alcohol % (ABV) - Graduated color bands help you know when you brew is ready, and larger fonts are so easy to read.

Check Price
03/14/2024 10:16 am GMT

Hydrometers are extremely reliable for original and final gravity measurements. Plus you don’t have to worry about calibration between brew days. However, they are temperature sensitive.

Most hydrometers are standardized to get an accurate measurement of 59 degrees Fahrenheit. That usually means you need to chill your wort down to get a proper reading.

In some cases, you can use a slightly warmer wort to get a reading and then use a temperature conversion calculator to get the measurement. But this can be risky because using too hot of a liquid can melt the wax inside that holds the metal balls, and will impact the way your hydrometer floats, making it unusable and inaccurate.

Here’s how to use a hydrometer

First, you’ll need a decent sample of your wort or beer to get a measurement. That’s where these tall flasks come in handy. Plastic ones are definitely recommended.

You fill the flask up with a sample and then drop your hydrometer in to see where it flows. The point where the top of the liquid meets the scale is your measurement.

Then you just toss that sample as it can cause an infection to your beer if you reintroduce it. That might not be the case. If you have great cleaning and sanitizing practices, but it’s better to be safe than sorry. Especially if you’re taking a sample for final gravity.

Refractometers measure the amount of light that is bent by the liquid called refraction, to give you the concentration of sugars in the wort. They can come in different scales, but the best one to get is one that has both brix and specific gravity. Where the blue area meets the white is your measurement.

One of the biggest positives for refractometers is that you only need a small sample, a few drops of the liquid to get an instant measurement. Unlike the hydrometer that needs to be submerged. This is great if you’re brewing small batches, or if you want to maximize your final amount of beer.

It’s also super helpful on brew day since you can take measurements during the mash, boil, and throughout the day, making sure you’re on target for your original gravity. Another positive is that refractometers have an auto temperature compensation, meaning you don’t have to worry about the temperature of your sample.

A negative for refractometers is that once fermentation has started and alcohol is present, the measurement you get is not as accurate because alcohol impacts the way light is refracted, but really this is more of an annoyance than a problem since there are calculators that you can use to find out your specific gravity of beer, as long as you have the original gravity reading.

Refractometers can also be a bit more pricey than hydrometers. But these days you can find some decent options for under $40, and they’re much less likely to break compared to a glass hydrometer.

Homebrewers Choice
Anpro Brix Refractometer for Homebrew

Much easier to read and less wasteful than a traditional (and fragile) hydrometer.

Check Price
03/14/2024 10:41 am GMT

Here’s how to use a refractometer.

First, make sure it is calibrated by placing a few drops of water on the plate. And looking through the eyepiece, the measurement should read zero bricks or 1.00 on the SG scale. If not, there’s usually a small screw that can be adjusted to correct.

To use it, just to collect a few drops of your liquid and place it on the plate and close the cover. Looking through the eyepiece, which is adjustable, you will see what the blue area meets the white, and that is your measurement.

Then just repeat throughout your brewing process, making sure you’re using a sanitized spoon if you’re collecting from a fermenting beer. And if it’s been fermenting, use a refractometer calculator to find your gravity.

Some other tools you use to calculate alcohol percentage are alcohol meters and Vin-o-meters. They’re only used to tell the final alcohol percentage of the beer or wine. The price ranges for these can vary from cheap to extremely expensive.

And while it’s helpful for distillers and vintners, it’s not as helpful for the home brewer.

Why Use a Refractometer?

As a homebrew beginner, you’ll most likely start off using a hydrometer to measure the specific gravity of your beer. This involves pulling off about half a pint of beer, throwing it in the testing tube, dropping the hydrometer in and reading the results.

I don’t know about you, but especially as a beginner I worried about my beer A LOT. I found myself wanting to check and re-check the progress of the fermentation every couple of days. What occurred to me after the first couple of batches was that I was “wasting” a lot of beer (Oh the horror!).

This wasn’t necessarily true, wasting implies that it was just being tipped down the sink; on the contrary, it’s very important to taste and test your beer as you go. It will give you a better handle on what the yeasties do at what time in the fermentation, and give you a chance to identify any problems early on!

As long as you are reading it right, and not wrong like I was.

However, it still bothered me. I ran a search on my concern, and came up with a couple of threads online about refractometers. Refractometers are instruments that measure the bending of light (refraction) through a liquid; the more sugar present, the more the light bends. Across the beverage industry they are used to measure the density of the sugars in the solution, or specific gravity; which is what we homebrewers usually use a hydrometer for.

The best thing about a refractometer is that it only takes a couple of drops of wort to get a reading! Crazy right?!

You will get a reading in Brix, and to convert this to our regular specific gravity readings you simply multiply by 4; e.g. 15 Brix = 1.060 SG. Here’s the conversion calculator.

The other thing I love about a refractometer is that you can take a reading while you’re still boiling, to see how close you are to your target gravity; no more kicking yourself once it’s in the carboy beacause your efficiency was off! (or did that only ever happen to me?)

Image of brix reading on a refractometer
Brix reading on a refractometer

The only tricky thing with a refractometer is that on its own it can’t give you a final gravity. You need to use a formula to calculate what the difference in Brix readings means in terms of FG.

Did I mention that I’m a lazy homebrewer? Well, I am; no fancy algebra for me on brewday! There are calculator tools out there online that will do all the translation for you, my favorite is over at More Beer. It will do all the hard work, and you can stop wasting your precious liquid gold.

Homebrewers Choice
Anpro Brix Refractometer for Homebrew

Much easier to read and less wasteful than a traditional (and fragile) hydrometer.

Check Price
03/14/2024 10:41 am GMT

Some myths and common misconceptions

One misconception might be that you need a hydrometer or refractometer to brew beer. It’s actually not true. You can technically brew without one, but it might be hard to tell if you have a finished beer or stuck fermentation.

And it’s definitely hard to tell what the final ABV is. You also might be tempted to put your hydrometer in a fermentor, and while technically this might work, it can be hard to read the measurement and it’s also a contamination risk. So I would avoid doing that if you can.

Lastly, you might hear that one of these is more accurate than the other, and that’s simply not true. If you use the tool properly and take good care of it, it should give you an accurate measurement every time. In my opinion, the best way to use these two tools is in tandem.

I like to use my hydrometer on brew day to get accurate measurements. Plus there’s something satisfying about dropping it into the flask.

It also gives me a chance to taste the wort and get a sense of how the final beer might taste. Then once the beers fermenting, I use a refractometer and conversion calculator to take my final gravity readings. That way I don’t have to take a large sample to get a reading.

If you have any questions about the things we discussed today, be sure to let me know.

What other kinds of 101’s would you like to see? My goal is to make home brewing simplified so that anyone could start brewing their own beer at home.

Frequently Asked Questions

Refractometer vs Hydrometer: Which is Better Suited for Alcohol Measurement?

Hydrometers assess alcohol potential by measuring liquid density, indicating sugar levels, while refractometers use light refraction to gauge sugar concentration in the wort, essential for alcohol production. The choice between refractometer vs hydrometer depends on brewer preference and brewing stage.

Hydrometer Calibration: How is it Done?

Hydrometers are standardized at 59°F for accurate readings. For differing temperatures, a temperature conversion calculator may be necessary to ensure the accuracy of the alcohol hydrometer measurements.

Refractometer Brewing Advantages: Why Choose a Refractometer?

Refractometers are prized for needing minimal sample volume, providing instant readings, and having auto temperature compensation. They are invaluable for real-time adjustments on brew day, significantly when brewing small batches or aiming to maximize beer yield.

Refractometer Post Fermentation: How is Accuracy Affected?

Alcohol presence post fermentation affects refractometer accuracy due to altered light refraction. However, with the original gravity and a refractometer calculator, accurate specific gravity readings can still be obtained, mitigating the refractometer alcohol measurement challenge.

Durable Hydrometer Alternatives: Are there Non-Glass Options?

Non-glass hydrometers present a durable alternative to traditional glass hydrometers, which are prone to breakage. These modern hydrometers maintain accuracy while offering enhanced durability, making them a viable option for brewers seeking longevity in their tools.

Similar Posts