Butterfinger in a Bottle: A Beer That’s Worth the Sticky Fingers!

Hey there, fellow beer enthusiasts! Have you ever thought about sipping on your favorite candy bar? No, I’m not talking about some Willy Wonka-style fantasy; I’m talking about the real, tangible, and oh-so-sippable world of craft beer innovations.

Today, we’re diving into something that sounds like it came straight out of a “dare to dream” brainstorming session: Butterfinger Beer. Yep, you read that right. So, let’s crack open this concept and see what’s brewing.

Concept of Butterfinger Beer

Imagine this: You’re walking through the aisles of your local craft beer shop, and there, among the sea of amber bottles and cans, you spot something that makes you do a double-take. Butterfinger Beer.

It sounds like a prank, doesn’t it? But trust me, it’s as real as the pint in your hand on a Friday night. So, where did this wild idea sprout from?

It’s the brainchild of a daring brewer who decided that the beer world needed a bit more fun, a bit more whimsy, and a whole lot more candy.

The idea was simple yet revolutionary: combine the nostalgic, crunchy, peanut-buttery goodness of a Butterfinger bar with the craft of brewing beer. The goal? To create a beverage that not only tickles your taste buds but also transports you back to those carefree days of trading candy bars on the schoolyard.

The Appeal of Butterfinger Beer

Now, who in their right mind would want to take a swig of this? Well, if you’re the kind of person who loves to push the flavor boundaries of what beer can be, then Butterfinger beer might just be your next favorite pint.

It’s designed for the adventurous drinker, the sweet-toothed reveler, and anyone who believes that dessert can indeed come in a bottle.

What sets Butterfinger beer apart isn’t just its flavor; it’s the audacity to blend the world of confectionery with the centuries-old craft of brewing. It’s a conversation starter, a curiosity piquer, and perhaps, a new notch on the belt of beer aficionados looking for their next unique sip.

Butterfinger-in-a-Bottle Recipes to Explore

Butterfinger Brew Bliss


  1. 1 pint of stout beer (preferably with chocolate notes)
  2. 1 shot of butterscotch schnapps
  3. Whipped cream and crushed Butterfinger candy for garnish


  1. Pour the stout beer into a pint glass, leaving some room at the top.
  2. Carefully add the shot of butterscotch schnapps to the beer.
  3. Top with whipped cream and sprinkle crushed Butterfinger candy over the whipped cream as garnish.

“Satisfy your sweet tooth and beer cravings in one sip!”

Caramel Nut Crunch Lager


  1. 1 pint of amber lager
  2. 1 shot of caramel vodka
  3. Crushed Butterfinger candy for mixing and garnish


  1. Start by mixing a tablespoon of crushed Butterfinger candy with the caramel vodka in a shaker.
  2. Pour the amber lager into a pint glass.
  3. Gently pour the infused caramel vodka over the back of a spoon into the lager to create a layered effect. Sprinkle some crushed Butterfinger candy on top for garnish.

“A nutty twist on your lager that brings a caramel crunch to every sip!”

Butterscotch Beer Delight


  1. 1 pint of vanilla porter
  2. 2 tablespoons of butterscotch syrup
  3. Whipped cream and crushed Butterfinger for garnish


  1. Pour the vanilla porter into a pint glass.
  2. Stir in the butterscotch syrup until well mixed.
  3. Top with whipped cream and garnish with crushed Butterfinger.

“Dive into a decadent delight where beer meets butterscotch!”

More Peanut Butter Beer Recipes:

Peanut Butter Porter with Chocolate Cocoa Nibs
How to Brew Chocolate Peanut Butter Porter

Brewing Process

Brewing Butterfinger beer is no small feat. It’s like conducting a symphony where the instruments are malt, hops, yeast, and… candy bars.

The process starts with a base beer, typically a rich, malty ale that can support the weight of the Butterfinger’s bold flavors. Then, through a combination of brewing alchemy and culinary magic, the essence of the Butterfinger is infused into the brew.

This might involve adding crushed candy bars directly into the mash, using flavor extracts, or even designing a special brewing process that mimics the candy’s taste profile.

The challenge here is balance. The brewer must walk a tightrope, ensuring that the beer retains its beer-ness while showcasing the unmistakable characteristics of a Butterfinger.

It’s about finding that sweet spot where the notes of chocolate, peanut butter, and that unique Butterfinger crunch harmonize with the hops, malt, and alcohol. No doubt, it’s a high-wire act that requires skill, patience, and a bit of daring. OK, on to the recipe.

Golden Butterfinger Ale

This homebrew recipe is designed for those who enjoy the sweet, nutty flavors of a Butterfinger candy bar melded with the craft of homebrewing. The goal is to create a medium-bodied ale with notes of caramel, chocolate, and peanut, finished with a hint of butterscotch. This unique brew is perfect for dessert or as a special treat.


For a 5-gallon batch:

  • 8 lbs Pale Malt (2-row)
  • 1 lb Caramel/Crystal Malt – 60L
  • 0.5 lb Munich Malt
  • 0.25 lb Chocolate Malt
  • 1 lb Lactose (Milk Sugar)
  • 1 oz Fuggle Hops (Bittering) – Boil 60 min
  • 1 oz East Kent Goldings Hops (Aroma) – Boil 5 min
  • 2 Vanilla Beans (split and scraped) – Add to secondary fermenter
  • 4 oz Butterscotch Schnapps – Add to secondary fermenter
  • 1 packet English Ale Yeast (e.g., Wyeast 1968 or Safale S-04)
  • 5 Crushed Butterfinger Bars – Add to boil and secondary (optional for added flavor)
  • Priming Sugar (for bottling)


Mash Process:

  • Heat 3.5 gallons of water to 165°F.
  • Add all grains to the mash tun and mix well to avoid dry spots. Stabilize the mash temperature at 152°F. Hold for 60 minutes.
  • Sparge the grains with 4.5 gallons of water at 170°F.


  • Bring the wort to a boil, then add 1 oz Fuggle hops for bittering. Boil for 60 minutes.
  • With 15 minutes left in the boil, add the lactose.
  • Add 5 crushed Butterfinger bars (optional) to the boil.
  • With 5 minutes remaining, add 1 oz East Kent Goldings hops for aroma.


  • Cool the wort to 68°F as quickly as possible and transfer to your fermenter.
  • Aerate the wort thoroughly and pitch the yeast.
  • Ferment at 68°F for 1-2 weeks until fermentation activity appears to cease.

Secondary Fermentation:

  • Transfer the beer to a secondary fermenter.
  • Add the split and scraped vanilla beans and butterscotch schnapps.
  • If desired, add additional crushed Butterfinger bars for enhanced flavor.
  • Allow to condition in the secondary fermenter for another 2 weeks.

Bottling: Prime with sugar and bottle. Allow the bottles to condition at room temperature for 2 weeks before chilling.

Enjoy: Serve chilled and enjoy the unique blend of flavors that reminisce a Butterfinger candy bar in a glass.

Note: Remember, homebrewing is both an art and a science. Feel free to adjust the recipe to suit your taste, perhaps by experimenting with different malt or hop varieties. Always ensure your equipment is sanitized to prevent contamination.

Taste Profile

So, you’ve got your hands on a glass of this golden, maybe slightly amber-hued elixir that promises to taste like your favorite childhood treat. What’s the first impression?

As you bring the glass closer, the aroma hints at a blend of sweet and savory – a tease of chocolate and peanut butter, with a backdrop of traditional beer undertones. The first sip? It’s like diving into a pool of nostalgia – but with a life jacket made of hops.

The taste is an intricate dance of flavors. Initially, you might catch the malty sweetness typical of ales, which then gives way to a subtle, not-overpowering wave of peanut butter and chocolate.

It’s not like biting into a Butterfinger; it’s more like a Butterfinger whispered its essence into the beer. The finish might leave you with a slight hoppy bitterness, ensuring you remember that, yes, this is indeed beer you’re drinking, not a liquid candy bar.

Pairing suggestions for Butterfinger beer are where fun meets culinary creativity. Imagine enjoying this with a hearty, spicy chili or balancing its sweetness with the saltiness of a soft pretzel. Or, for the ultimate dessert beer, pair it with a slice of vanilla cheesecake to complement its richness.

Pros and Cons of Butterfinger Beer

Now, as much as we’d love to say Butterfinger beer is the Willy Wonka invention we’ve all been waiting for, let’s be real – it’s not for everyone.

Here are some pros and cons to consider:


  • Uniqueness: It’s a standout choice in a sea of IPAs and stouts.
  • Nostalgia Factor: It tugs at the heartstrings of your inner child.
  • Conversation Starter: It’s the kind of beer that gets people talking, whether they love it or hate it.


  • Niche Appeal: Its unique taste might not cater to traditional beer lovers.
  • Sweetness Overload: Depending on the brewer’s hand, it could lean too heavily on the sweet side, potentially overshadowing the beer’s complexity.
  • Availability Issues: Being a novelty, it might be harder to find than your go-to six-pack.

Consumer Reception

So, what’s the word on the street about Butterfinger beer? It’s a mixed bag, as you might expect. Some beer enthusiasts are all in, praising its innovative approach to flavor and its bold departure from the norm. They love the novelty, the creativity, and the sheer audacity of brewing a beer inspired by a candy bar.

On the other hand, purists might turn their noses up, arguing that beer should taste like, well, beer. They respect the craft but would rather stick to their hops and barley without the candy aisle interference.

In terms of market performance, Butterfinger beer tends to be a limited release, making it a sought-after commodity for collectors and enthusiasts. Its rarity adds to its allure, with each batch eagerly anticipated by its growing fan base.

Let’s keep the momentum going as we delve into how Butterfinger beer stands up in the digital arena and address some burning questions you might have about this intriguing concoction.

Ratings Section

When it comes to how Butterfinger beer fares on the web, it’s a fascinating case study. Beer rating sites and craft beer forums are abuzz with discussions and reviews. On platforms like Untappd and RateBeer, Butterfinger beer has carved out its niche.

You’ll see ratings that range from high praise for its innovative approach and enjoyable taste to more moderate reviews from those who find the concept more appealing than the execution.

What’s clear is that Butterfinger beer elicits a strong reaction, either way, making it a must-try for the curious.

Compared to other candy-flavored beers – yes, they’re a thing – Butterfinger beer holds its own, offering a unique taste experience that’s hard to find elsewhere. It’s a testament to the beer’s novelty and the brewer’s skill in capturing the essence of a beloved candy bar in liquid form.


How does Butterfinger beer compare to traditional beers?

Butterfinger beer is a departure from traditional beers, offering a unique blend of candy bar flavors with the familiar base of an ale or lager. It’s a craft beer enthusiast’s adventurous alternative to standard beer flavors.

Can you taste the actual Butterfinger in the beer?

While it doesn’t taste like you’re drinking a melted Butterfinger, the beer is infused with the candy’s signature flavors of chocolate and peanut butter, creating a unique taste profile that hints at the classic candy bar.

Where can I find Butterfinger beer?

Availability can vary, as it’s often released in limited quantities. Check with local craft breweries, specialty beer shops, or online craft beer marketplaces for the latest releases.

Is Butterfinger beer a seasonal offering?

It depends on the brewery making it. Some might release it as a special one-off or seasonal treat, while others could include it in their lineup more regularly based on popularity.

How do brewers infuse the Butterfinger flavor into the beer?

Techniques can vary, but methods include adding crushed Butterfinger bars during the brewing process, using flavor extracts, or designing the beer’s malt profile to mimic the candy’s taste.

What is the alcohol content of Butterfinger beer?

The alcohol by volume (ABV) can range depending on the brew, but it typically falls within the standard craft beer range of 5-8%.

Is Butterfinger beer suitable for people with nut allergies?

Given the flavor profile, those with nut allergies should proceed with caution and consult the brewery for specific ingredient details.

How should Butterfinger beer be served?

Like most craft beers, it’s best enjoyed chilled. Serving it in a glass can enhance the aroma and flavor experience.

Can Butterfinger beer be used in cooking or baking?

Absolutely! Its unique flavor profile makes it an interesting ingredient for desserts or savory dishes that could benefit from a hint of peanut butter and chocolate.

What are some similar candy-flavored beers?

The craft beer world is full of innovative flavors, including beers inspired by candies like Snickers, Twix, and even gummy bears. Each offers a unique taste adventure for the daring drinker.


Butterfinger beer stands as a bold emblem of the craft beer industry’s endless creativity and willingness to push the boundaries of traditional brewing.

Whether you’re a fan of the idea or skeptical of mixing candy with beer, there’s no denying the skill and innovation that goes into creating such a brew. It’s a liquid homage to childhood nostalgia, wrapped in the grown-up pleasure of enjoying a cold beer.

As we raise our glasses to the brewers who dare to dream and the drinkers who welcome these dreams with an open palate, let’s toast to the continued evolution of craft beer. Who knows what flavors the future may hold? But one thing’s for sure: the journey will be anything but boring.

Similar Posts