Indulge Your Taste Buds: Discover the Best Peanut Butter Beers on the Market

Seeking the best peanut butter beers? Look no further. Our guide ranks top-rated peanut butter-infused brews, breaks down the crafting techniques, and suggests pairings that elevate their unique taste.

Whether you’re a casual drinker or a connoisseur, we’ll help you navigate the beloved blend of nutty and malt flavors that define these distinctive ales and stouts.

Key Takeaways

  • Peanut butter beers are growing in popularity, marrying a sense of nostalgia with sophisticated flavors for an adult twist on a childhood staple.
  • Crafting peanut butter beer is an art, using ingredients like powdered peanut butters, extracts, or nuts to nail the unique flavor without messing up beer quality.
  • Peanut butter beers come in various forms, including Peanut Butter Milk Stout and PB&J Milkshake IPA, allowing for a diverse tasting experience across different beer styles.

The Allure of Peanut Butter in Your Pint

Peanut butter beers draw upon deep-rooted nostalgia and American culture, given the staple role of peanut butter in our diets. The flavor provides comforting notes that resonate with consumers, both psychologically and gustatorily, morphing a simple childhood favorite into an elegant adult beverage.

These beers are appreciated for their knack in triggering nostalgic childhood memories among adults, a key factor contributing to their success in the craft market. And the numbers don’t lie – there has been a reported 35% increase in the number of peanut butter beers available since 2019, underscoring their burgeoning consumer popularity.

The irresistible combination of peanut butter’s creamy, salty, sweet taste with the nuanced flavors of beer appeals to a broad audience. These beers blend sweet and savory sensations that satisfy childhood cravings in an adult-friendly beverage format.

Here are some examples of beers that combine the flavors of peanut butter and beer:

  • Peanut Butter Milk Stout
  • Peanut Butter Porter
  • Peanut Butter Chocolate Stout
  • Peanut Butter Blonde Ale

These base beer options, crafted by craft brewers, open up a world of enjoyment for good beer lovers.

Crafting the Perfect Peanut Butter Brew

The creation of peanut butter beer is a meticulous process that requires a balance of flavors and techniques.

Brewers use everything from:

  • whole nuts
  • real peanut butter
  • peanut butter powder
  • peanut flavor extracts

to achieve the desired flavor profile. PB2 Powdered Peanut Butter is a popular choice among brewers for its ability to provide flavor without adding oils that compromise head retention and mouthfeel.

Tin Whiskers Brewing Company adds powdered peanut butter post-fermentation at warm temperatures before packaging to extract flavors effectively into the beer. Meanwhile, other brewers use a three-layer approach involving PB2, honey-roasted peanuts, and peanut extract to enhance the depth and complexity of the peanut butter flavor.

The brewing process necessitates precise calibration of mash temperature and boil duration to strike the perfect balance between chocolate and peanut butter flavors.

Experimentation has led to a variety of styles, including:

  • Peanut Butter Porters
  • Nutty Brown Ales
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter Stouts
  • PB&J Milkshake IPAs
  • Peanut Butter Coffee Stouts

These innovative variations showcase the delicious combination of chocolate and peanut butter in the world of beer, especially in the form of a chocolate peanut butter porter.

Top Picks: Peanut Butter Porters That Impress

Speaking of peanut butter porters, Liquid Mechanics Brewing’s Peanut Butter Porter distinguishes itself by harmoniously blending the sweetness of peanut butter with a hint of smoky porter. Another notable mention is Dangerous Man Brewing’s Peanut Butter Porter, which features prominent flavors of coffee and peanut butter, providing a unique twist on the classic porter style.

Back Forty Beer Company is known for their Peanut Butter Porter, brewed with natural peanut butter extract and crushed peanuts for an authentic, delightful peanut butter flavor.

But the list doesn’t stop there. The B.O.B.’s Peanut Butter Porter uses peanuts, chocolate, vanilla, brown sugar, and milk for a complex flavor, while Nuddy Buddy Peanut Butter Porter from Old Mill Brewpub pairs roasted peanuts with fair-trade Mexican vanilla, evoking the taste of a childhood favorite cookie.

DuClaw Brewing from Maryland also deserves a mention for their Sweet Baby Jesus! beer. It’s definitely worth trying. This brew is frequently listed among the best peanut butter porters, and with its memorable flavor profile, it’s not hard to see why.

The Stout Sensation: Chocolate Peanut Butter Stouts to Savor

For those who favor richer, creamier beers, exploring the world of chocolate peanut butter stouts might be an enticing option, including the indulgent imperial milk stout. Take Left Hand Brewing’s Peanut Butter Milk Stout Nitro, for example.

The stout greets you with the inviting scents of roasted coffee, milk chocolate, and vanilla cream. Its rich flavors intertwine sweet and savory notes of peanut butter and brown sugar.

Another notable stout is Odd Side Ales’ Peanut Butter Cup Stout. This brew brings together chocolate and peanut butter in a rich seasonal favorite, complemented by a nitro version with a creamier texture.

And then there’s Belching Beaver Brewery’s Mexican Chocolate Peanut Butter Stout, which provides a nuanced blend with cinnamon and coffee enhancing the core peanut butter flavor. The liquid peanut butter cup sensation in these stouts is truly remarkable.

For those who want an intense experience, the Bourbon Barrel Traxxx Night Fury offers just that. This stout is aged on:

  • peanut butter
  • coconut
  • vanilla beans
  • cacao nibs
  • bourbon

providing a complex and indulgent tasting experience.

Beyond the Basics: Innovative Peanut Butter Beer Variations

Breweries are not limiting themselves to the basics in the realm of peanut butter beers; they’re indeed getting rather inventive. Decadent Ales’ Peanut Butter S’mores IPA and Untitled Art’s Peanut Butter Jelly Imperial Stout are perfect examples of this, creatively interpreting classic American treats into complex beer experiences.

Drekker Brewing Company pushes the boundary further with CHONK Peanut Butter & Jelly, a pastry/smoothie sour that encapsulates the PB&J sandwich essence in a tart beer form.

Experimental brews showcasing peanut butter have expanded into various beer styles like brown ales, Milkshake IPAs, and even fruit beers, offering drinkers a multitude of flavor dimensions. In the world of craft beer, this unique concoction could be considered a “peanut butter jelly crime” against traditional brewing norms.

Brewers use innovative additives such as Brewer’s Best Peanut Butter Flavoring and spicy peanut butter to create unique peanut beer experiences, perfectly complementing the different beer styles like IPAs.

Pairing Perfection: Foods That Elevate Peanut Butter Beers

The enjoyment of relishing a peanut butter beer can be remarkably heightened when harmonized with appropriate foods. For instance, white-chocolate-infused peanut butter enhances dark and sweet peanut butter beers, creating a dessert experience akin to enjoying shortbread cookies or biscotti with espresso.

If you’re up for a decadent dessert, a homemade creamy peanut butter ice cream paired with a chocolate stout results in an exquisite beer float dessert. Sweet, cream, or milk stouts are ideal for pairing with rich and sweet peanut butter desserts, complementing their sweetness perfectly.

For a simple snack pairing, reach for some salted nuts. These can amplify the enjoyment of peanut butter beers by complementing their flavor and refreshing the palate.

Personal Favorites: A Curated List of Must-Try Peanut Butter Beers

To assist you in navigating the realm of peanut butter beers, I’d like to share a few personal favorites. Sweet Baby Jesus by DuClaw Brewing Company is a hallmark of peanut butter beers that deserves a spot on any list. Notable beers also include Peanut Butter Porter from Liquid Mechanics Brewing and the robust Chocolate Peanut Butter Stout from Rapp Brewing.

From Ohio comes several selections like Peanut Butter Cup Coffee Porter from Willoughby Brewing and Roadside Peanut Butter Porter by Crooked Handle Brewing. And from California, the Peanut Butter Milk Stout by Belching Beaver Brewing adds a creamy complement to this rich assortment.

But no matter where you’re based, there’s likely a peanut butter beer for you to try. This diverse selection illustrates the broad scope of peanut butter beers, each with their own take on the creamy, nutty goodness that has captured the taste buds of enthusiasts.


After this whirlwind tour of peanut butter beers, it’s clear that this trend is here to stay. From the nostalgic allure of peanut butter in a pint to the careful craft of creating the perfect brew, peanut butter beers offer a unique flavor experience that resonates with many beer enthusiasts.

Whether you’re a fan of porters, stouts, or looking for something a little different, there’s a peanut butter beer out there for you. So why not explore this delicious niche? You might just find your new favorite brew.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is there a peanut butter beer?

Yes, there is a peanut butter beer with cascading aromas of buttery peanuts and dark chocolate, highly coveted by beer drinkers.

What does peanut butter beer taste like?

Peanut butter beer taste like a rich and roasted stout with nutty and savory flavors, often including notes of chocolate and coffee.

Who makes the best peanut butter stout?

Check out the top 10 peanut butter beers brewed in America for some great options.

Who makes peanut butter porter beer?

Saugatuck Brewing Company makes peanut butter porter beer in Michigan.

How is peanut butter beer made?

Peanut butter beer is made by using whole nuts, real peanut butter, peanut butter powder, or peanut flavor extracts during the brewing process, which requires careful adjustments of mash temperature and boil duration to balance the flavors.

Similar Posts