Beer Lovers Confess: These Are Their Secret Guilty Pleasures

What’s your guilty pleasure beer? That one brew you love but might hesitate to mention in beer-snob circles.

We asked our community of beer lovers to share their secret indulgences, and the responses didn’t disappoint.

From nostalgic classics to quirky choices, these guilty pleasure beers reveal a lot about how beer can be both personal and universal.

Whether you’re a craft beer connoisseur or a casual drinker, these picks might just make you feel less guilty about your own hidden favorites.

Top 10 Guilty Pleasure Beers According to Beer Lovers

1. St Stan’s (Microbrewery in Modesto, CA)

“St Stan’s…a microbrewery near my hometown in Modesto, CA.” – Scott H.

St Stan’s holds a special place for locals, proving that beer is as much about memories as it is about flavor. Nostalgia often plays a big role in our beer preferences.

2. Chimay, Blue Label

“Chimay, Blue Label.” – Shawn P.

A classic Belgian beer that might not feel like a guilty pleasure to some, but for others, it’s the indulgent richness that makes them hesitate to admit their love.

3. Brador (Molson’s Retro Brew)

“Brador, made by Molson years ago. Only available in Canada.” – Jimi R.

This vintage brew is a blast from the past. The scarcity of Brador makes it a cherished memory for those who had the chance to try it.

4. West Coast Craft (Hard to Get in Ohio)

“Hard to get in Ohio… from the west coast (Oregon).” – Walter S.

Sometimes, what makes a beer a guilty pleasure is its exclusivity. West Coast brews hold a mystique for fans in other regions.

5. The 12th One

“Probably the 12th one.” – Felix R.

A tongue-in-cheek response that reminds us sometimes the best guilty pleasure beer isn’t the beer itself but the experience of sharing laughs and stories over multiple rounds.

6. Busch Light

“Busch Light, but only in a fishing boat.” – Mike T.

Some beers are situational guilty pleasures—Busch Light on a fishing boat becomes more than just a drink; it’s part of the adventure.

7. Zima

“Does Zima count?” – Jessica L.

This ‘90s throwback polarizes drinkers, but for some, the nostalgia outweighs the mockery.

8. Old Milwaukee

“Old Milwaukee…because it was my dad’s beer.” – Greg A.

Old Milwaukee is a guilty pleasure steeped in sentimentality, reminding us how personal connections shape our beer preferences.

9. Natural Light (Natty)

“Natty, because it’s cheap and does the job.” – Kevin J.

A true guilty pleasure for its affordability and efficiency, Natty proves that sometimes simplicity reigns supreme.

10. Michelob Ultra

“Michelob Ultra…because I’m trying to convince myself it’s healthy.” – Sarah M.

A classic example of indulging while attempting to maintain balance, Michelob Ultra fits the bill for many fitness-conscious beer lovers.

Our guilty pleasure beers tell stories—of nostalgia, exclusivity, or just plain fun.

Whether it’s a rare find from a microbrewery, a quirky retro favorite, or a widely available classic, there’s no shame in enjoying what you love.

Beer, after all, is meant to bring people together. So, what’s your guilty pleasure beer? Share in the comments below—we’d love to hear your story!