10 Discontinued Beers That Deserve a Comeback: Do You Agree?

Imagine walking into a bar and finding your favorite beer—a brew you’ve cherished for years—no longer exists. It’s a bittersweet reminder of the ever-changing beer landscape.

We posed a nostalgic question to our community of beer lovers: What discontinued beer do you wish would make a comeback?

The answers poured in faster than a freshly tapped keg. From cult classics to small-town treasures, here are the top brews people are still dreaming of.

Top 10 Most-Missed Beers

Schlitz Malt Liquor

A true icon of its time, Schlitz Malt Liquor captured the hearts of many beer enthusiasts with its bold flavor and iconic branding.

It’s clear from the comments that it still holds a special place in many hearts.

“Schlitz Malt Liquor 😃” – Jaime O.

Heineken Dark

For fans of richer, darker brews, Heineken Dark was the go-to choice. Known for its smooth finish and robust flavor, this beer left a lasting impression on those who enjoyed it during their bartending days.

“Heineken Dark. My favorite during my bartending days!” – Alan W.

Leinenkugel (Original Family-Owned Recipe)

Leinenkugel’s fans remember the original family-owned recipe fondly. The rich, authentic taste is missed by many who associate it with simpler times and quality craftsmanship.

“Leinenkugel when it was still family-owned, and the recipe was untampered with!” – Scott B. N.

Mickey’s Big Mouth Malt Liquor

Mickey’s Big Mouth wasn’t just a beer—it was an experience. With its iconic wide-mouth bottle and distinctive malt flavor, it remains a nostalgic favorite among fans of old-school brews.

“Mickey’s Big Mouth Malt Liquor!” – Eric L.

Killian’s Red (Original Recipe)

A staple in the amber lager category, Killian’s Red in its original form was cherished for its balance of malt sweetness and subtle hop bitterness.

Fans still lament its evolution over the years.

“I really miss the original Killian’s Red recipe. Nothing else compares.” – Anonymous

Olympia Beer

Olympia Beer’s motto, “It’s the Water,” resonated with fans who appreciated its crisp, refreshing taste.

This regional favorite has a cult following that wishes for its revival.

“Olympia Beer—no summer barbecue was complete without it.” – John T.

Zima

Love it or hate it, Zima had a devoted fanbase. This malt beverage’s unique, clear appearance and citrusy taste made it a staple of ’90s nostalgia.

“Zima! It wasn’t a beer, but it was my go-to for so many parties.” – Sarah L.

Red Wolf

A true gem from Anheuser-Busch, Red Wolf was known for its amber color and smooth flavor.

Fans often wonder why this beloved brew didn’t last longer.

“Red Wolf was the best beer they ever made, and it’s gone forever!” – Mike H.

Henry Weinhard’s Private Reserve

Henry Weinhard’s Private Reserve was more than a beer—it was a legacy. With its premium ingredients and careful brewing process, it’s a name that still evokes fond memories.

“I’ll always remember Henry Weinhard’s. A true classic.” – Linda P.

Rainier Ale

Known affectionately as “Green Death” due to its powerful flavor and high alcohol content, Rainier Ale was a Pacific Northwest favorite.

Fans still sing its praises for being bold and unfiltered.

“Rainier Ale—nothing else could hit the spot like it did.” – Dave G.

These beers are more than just beverages—they’re memories in a bottle.

From regional specialties to nationwide icons, each one reflects the deep, personal connections people have with their favorite brews.

What about you? Which discontinued beer do you wish would make a triumphant return?